I asked this question about a week ago on homelab and didn’t get very much input, so I hope I can get more help here.

I have been looking at replacing my L3 switch at the gateway of my network & the OPNsense DEC850 seems to have all the features I want, mainly, vlans, 10 GB wan, multiple 2.5 GB lan, & open firmware. Does anyone have experience with this router/ are there better routers out there that do similar setups? I have experience with Cisco hardware and am willing to learn new syntax so I am not too worried about the CLI, but I heard that opnsense’s docs are a bit thin.

  • Shabby4582@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    15 hours ago

    I personally find the machines from opnsense to be a little overpriced, but I’m now more used to running my own hardware. They look like nice boxes though, you’re not going to be disappointed with it. If you’re in the US, take a look at Protectli as they’re pretty great too. If you’re not, the shipping might be a bit of a big ask (or not, have a look). They can stick coreboot on for you to be super open etc and support all the features you want. Customer support is pretty good too.

    Are you using the box as a switch? That’s how I read your post, apologies if I misread it. While it’s straightforward enough to include multiple NICs in the same LAN, I’m not sure they are handled in hardware on these boxes, which just means the cpu is making more heat doing something it’s not that good at compared to a dedicated chip. If you’re fine with that, that’s a fair enough way of doing it. For me it’s more standard to just run the router into a dedicated switch, even though ultimately that’s more expensive. I’d love a DIY switch though.

    I went from a consumer router to a ubiquiti edge series router and I found that a jump…then I landed in Opnsense land and it was a huge jump again. Totally worth it in my opinion. Really value being able to spin up my own firewall from parts (or in proxmox if the machine shits the bed, which has happened).

    https://homenetworkguy.com/ and his accompanying YouTube channel were absolute godsends for me setting opnsense up the first time. Now I’m a complete opnsense convert and cannot really see any reason to change in the future.