• 0 Posts
  • 60 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: January 3rd, 2024

help-circle




  • That’s what resonates for me.

    We don’t have email instances, and email providers similarly block un-desired content, but there’s not a big fuss about missing out on specific types of spam. Lol.

    Similarly Internet service providers actually also block big blocks of malware providing domains, and accidentally sometimes block some great piracy resources. People who care learn to use a VPN or switch providers. Everyone else doesn’t have to think about it.

    I’ll argue that The Fediverse also carries extremely similar switching cost as an email or Internet provider. For an average user, “Let folks you care to inform know where you moved, and maybe copy over some favorite bookmarks.”

    Sure, different providers do try to bring different lenses on the same federated content, but most people aren’t served well by thinking about it on day one.

    I think shifting to the term provider is a lot more honest to the user about what to expect.















  • Mastodon doesn’t by design, so they’re gonna have a much, much harder time there.

    In theory, yes. But what early switching folks are reporting is that the total impressions are much lower on Mastodon, but the total engagement is much higher, for the same effort.

    Which is confusing unless we factor in what we know about Twitter farming bot account on purpose to create an inflated appearance of success.

    Of course, there’s still the matter of Twitter genuinely has orders of magnitude more users. So as an either/or proposition, no way does it, yet, make sense to ditch Twitter for Mastodon.

    But for the value-to-reach ratio, with the same effort applied to both, anyway, Mastodon is actually already a better value than Twitter.

    All that to say, yeah, Twitter is better, purely due to the user base, and Mastodon’s algorithm actually treats creators better. Which we kind of already knew, as it was created by people fed up with Twitters abusive algorithms.